For those who have been trading stocks one may be
familiar with the VIX which is a market sentiment
indicator based on the balance of option buying and
selling in the market. In essence it indicates the
levels of fear or complacency in the market, and is
used as a contrarian indicator. In other words if
everyone is very relaxed and calm, the indicator is
low, so it is time to do the opposite and sell, similarly
when the readings are high with fear in the markets,
it is time to buy. The VIX slogan is " when the
VIX is low it's time to go, when the VIX is high it's
time to buy". Currencies too have a market sentiment
indicator and is called the US Dollar Index.
The
US dollar index is one that has been around
a long time. The start of the index is March
1973. This is when the world’s biggest
nations met in Washington D.C. and all agreed
to allow their currencies to float freely against
each. The start of the index is also known as
the “base period”. but is little
used by retail currency traders as generally
they have never heard of it. It is a futures’
index which is quoted 24 hours a day seven days
a week and is on the NYBOT (New York Board of
Trade), and represents the relationship between
the US dollar and six major currencies.
How
the US Dollar Index used in currency trading decisions?
By using a combination of candlestick technical analysis,
support and resistance and moving averages, one can
form a view of the US Dollar based on long term trends,
possible short term and long term reversals and changes
in market sentiment, against the major currencies in
the basket. It is important to understand, that like
it or not, the US Dollar dictates the trends in all
the major currencies, and therefore this index provides
an excellent starting point for determining the US Doll
ar’s
strength or weakness in relation to the currency pairs.
REASONS
FOR A MAJOR TURN IN THE US DOLLAR
BULLISH
DOLLAR
While the Dollar Index hits multi-decade lows and as
the euro continues to trade within striking distance
of record highs, savvy investors are beginning to wonder
if the current market conditions present a unique opportunity
to buy the US currency at ultra-cheap levels. However,
with the Federal Reserve aggressively cutting rates
and talk of an oncoming US recession dominating the
airwaves, investors are understandably concerned about
buying the beleaguered buck at this time Here are a
few reasons why being a dollar-bull may be a good idea
this year, even if the United States experiences a serious
economic slowdown:
Here
are a few reasons why being a dollar-bull may be a good
idea this year, even if the United States experiences
a serious economic slowdown:
Dollar near all-time lows:
Fed
ahead of the curve everyone else is behind:
Lower
US Interest Rates and a stimulus plan:
Lower dollar:
Deep US recession:
Bargain
opportunity?
Will
the dollar outperform?
US
economic rebound and a resurgence of the dollar?
Better
US corporate profits, improvement in the trade
deficit?
Dollar
becomes a safe-haven play?
THE
FEDERAL RESERVE IS AHEAD OF THE CURVE
-
Fed lowers the cost of capital by 40% in just
6 months
- Makes adjustable rate mortgages more affordable
When it comes to the US economy what is the elephant
in the room? Clearly it is housing. Would the
Federal Reserve have cut rates by a whopping 125bp
in just one month if the housing sector was not
in such terrible trouble?
Dollar
Index Through 1998-2008
When
the subprime crisis became front-page news in August
2007, the Federal Reserve responded quickly to the growing
problems in the credit markets. It dropped the discount
rate by 50bp to 5.75% and provided liquidity to the
banks through its open market operations. Other central
banks followed a similar path, but the Fed was the first
major central bank to take the easing process a step
further by lowering the Fed funds rate a full 50bp in
September. Then, while other central banks debated the
merits of lowering rates or staying put, the Fed did
not hesitate and continued to ease aggressively by cutting
rates another 50bp in December and then a whopping 75bp
in January. Altogether, the Fed reduced rates by 175bp
in just six months and dropped the Fed Funds rate from
5% to 3%, providing a near 40% reduction in the cost
of short-term capital for the US banking system.
WHILE EVERYONE ELSE IS BEHIND IT
- ECB stubbornness could lead to a severe contraction
in Europe later in the year
- BOE already forced to lower rates
- As easing accelerates, European currencies lose their
principal advantage of higher interest rates
In contrast to the Fed, other central banks have been
very slow to act; EU and UK monetary officials proved
to be much less responsive to the crisis. The Bank of
England stubbornly refused to boost liquidity; consequently,
within a few months, Sterling Libor rates (the rates
which banks charge each other for overnight loans) spiked
higher amidst the rapidly tightening credit conditions,
forcing the Monetary Policy Committee to begrudgingly
reduce interest rates by 25bp in December and by another
25bp in February 2008. In the meantime, while the European
Central Bank did move quickly to add liquidity to the
system by temporarily loaning funds to banks, they left
the rates unchanged at 4.00%, providing no help to businesses.
Meanwhile, reports in both the areas have started to
signal a significant deterioration of economic conditions.
With global growth anticipated to slow further this
year, these cracks could turn into canyons, which may
force the Bank of England and European Central Bank
to make up for lost time and slash rates much more aggressively
in the second half of 2008. Should that be the case,
both currencies would lose their attractiveness as their
yields quickly decline. Meanwhile, the dollar should
rally as speculators and investors dump euros and pounds.
In short, while most of the bad news is already priced
into the dollar, the markets may be underestimating
the potential risks to other advanced economies. Currencies
are always a relative bet, and the dollar can appreciate,
even in a challenging economic environment if its trading
partners are faring worse.
LOWER US INTEREST RATES + STIMULUS PLAN = US
ECONOMIC REBOUND?
- Fed easing stabilizes the housing market
- US consumer boosted by stimulus package
- US economy merely slows, does not contract
- No need for additional rate cuts
Whether you want to call it a "panic response"
or an aggressive attempt to lessen the blow of an oncoming
recession, the Federal Reserve's rapid rate cuts should
provide some soothing relief for the US economy. First,
while the massive correction in the housing market is
not over yet, mortgage holders may get some respite
from their mortgages as interest rates ease and the
government, in conjunction with mortgage lenders, offers
30-day freezes on foreclosures, allowing borrowers to
modify their loans in order to make them affordable.
If the Federal Reserve and the US government can curtail
the growing number of foreclosures, it could help stabilize
the housing sector and remove one of the biggest headwinds
to US economic growth.
Meanwhile, an economic stimulus plan will start to pay
out as early as May, with many taxpayers receiving a
rebate of between $600-1200. The hope of Congress and
the Bush Administration is that the money will boost
consumer spending and help rejuvenate the services sector.
The plan also includes adjustments that will allow small
businesses to expense, rather than depreciate certain
asset purchases. As a result, businesses will be more
likely to keep their workers, exerting less pressure
on the unemployment rolls.
While these policy initiatives won't necessarily work
wonders overnight, they may greatly reduce the risk
of a full-blown US recession. With markets already pricing
in a doomsday scenario for the US economy, any evidence
of growth—even if it's relatively modest—will
be viewed positively by the currency market and could
lead the dollar to rebound while investor sentiment
improves.
BIG BUSINESSES BENEFIT FROM A WEAK US DOLLAR
MAY ACTUALLY BE A BOOST
- US multi-nationals benefit from lower dollar, profits
surprise to the upside
- US stock markets bounce as a result attracting foreign
investment and demand for the dollar
- US trade balance improves as exports boom, contributing
to growth
The
tax code changes included in the US government's
economic stimulus plan are geared towards consumers
and small businesses, but what about large multi-national
corporations that bring in millions of dollars
in profits and hire thousands of workers each
year? These firms are already getting some help
in the form of the weak US dollar.
The
decline in the currency has turned US-made goods
into relatively cheap products compared to those
from the euro zone or UK. For example, the US-based
aircraft giant, Boeing, beat out Europe's Airbus
in orders during 2007. If the market for aircraft
isn't as fertile as it was in 2007, these companies
will likely be forced to be even more competitive
in 2008, and the low exchange values could provide
US corporations with a crucial edge in winning
more business. This dynamic is not only good for
the domestic economy, but it is also positive
for the US trade deficit and stock market. If
investors from abroad decide to buy up stock in
US corporations, the influx of capital into the
U.S. will actually end up helping the greenback
structurally as the US trade deficit contracts
and US investment flows expand.
US
Trade Balance from 2002-2008
COULD
RECESSION BE A BOOM FOR THE BUCK?
- Paradoxically, worst-case scenario for the US economy
could be positive for the dollar
- Global economic slowdown will lead to liquidation
of risky assets
- Demand for US treasury bills and bonds will soar
- Dollar will benefit as safe-haven repository
As we mentioned above, capital flows into US assets
can provide a boost to the dollar from a supply / demand
point of view, but the greenback can gain even under
the worst-case scenario of a severe US economic recession.
Presently, global central banks are worried about the
stability of the financial markets, leaving investors
concerned as well, which is why we've seen waves of
risk aversion sweep through the financial markets. If
conditions become worse—be it from a major corporate
or government default, or some sort of systematic failure—there
is little doubt that global financial markets will become
panicked and turn volatile once again. Subsequently,
investors will flee to safe haven assets, and US Treasuries
tend to benefit greatly during such times. If the shift
in funds is large enough, the surge in demand may quickly
boost the value of Treasuries, and therefore US dollars
as investors flock to safety. Paradoxically enough,
in times of trouble, the dollar is likely to stand as
the currency of last resort and therefore, even if you
are not bullish on the prospects of the U.S. or global
economy, you may still want to be long dollars.
BEARISH
DOLLAR
With the Dollar Index hovering near all-time lows, some
analysts see bargain. However, buying dollars may be
as tough as catching a falling knife. None of the factors
that have been responsible for the decline of the greenback
disappeared. In fact, if anything, the situation has
only become worse.
Here
are a few reasons, despite the steep decline, why being
a dollar bear may still be a good idea in 2008
US
slowdown turns into a severe recession:
Low
rates make lead to USD carry trade:
Low
dollar leads to less foreign investment:
Gulf
states de-peg from the dollar:
10m
households foreclosed, US consumer devastated
Will
the Dollar be the new Yen?
How
does the US finance the deficit?
Dollar
losses it reserve status dominance
US
SLOWDOWN TURNS INTO A RECESSION
-
10M households in foreclosure
- Massive decline in consumer demand
When
it comes to the US economy, what is the elephant
in the room? Clearly, it is housing. Would the
Federal Reserve have cut rates by a whopping 125bp
in just one month if the housing sector were not
in such terrible trouble?
Absolutely not, While the direct impact of housing
accounts for only 5% of GDP, analysts estimate
that since 2002, housing’s indirect influence
on the US economy, via the finance and retail
sectors, could be as much as 40%. Little wonder
then that the greatest fear facing US policy makers
is the possibility of 10 million households facing
foreclosure in the next 24 months. The situation
appears so dire because of a deadly combination
of rapidly declining housing prices in conjunction
with a massive wave of resets of Adjustable Rate
Mortgages.
Dollar
Index Through 1998-2008
As
poorly capitalized home owners are faced with the prospect
of markedly higher monthly mortgage payments while the
equity in their houses deteriorates, many find themselves
“upside down” and owning more of their loans
than their homes are worth. In such circumstances, some
home owners have chosen to simply mail the keys to the
house to their bank and default on the loan—a
move derisively termed as “jingle mail.”
If the beleaguered mortgage payers decide to default
en masse, the repercussions for the US economy would
be disastrous; the result of which is the possibility
of many key players in the financial sector being forced
into bankruptcy. FDIC insurance notwithstanding, the
ripple effects could endanger assets of fiscally healthy
consumers as well, and the concomitant contraction in
demand would bring economic activity to a halt. With
consumption making up more than 70% of the US economy,
a sudden and sharp decline in net worth would push the
US economy from slowdown into a full blow recession,
necessitating further rate cuts from the Fed.
THE US DOLLAR BECOMES THE NEW JAPANESE YEN
- Dollar interest rates decline to 1% or less
- Europe, Australia, New Zealand, and the UK maintain
or increase their interest rates
- Dollar comes under constant pressure from carry trade
flows
Anyone that is familiar with the forex markets knows
about the "carry trade"—the method by
which traders buy high-yielding currencies, like the
New Zealand dollar, and fund the trade in currencies
with low interest rates, like the Japanese yen, in order
to reap the greatest profits. While investing in carry
trades is never a sure bet, (they are prone to sharp
reversals during periods of turmoil in financial markets
leading to potential losses), the prospect of raking
in additional profits via accumulated interest always
keeps risk-seekers coming back for more.
Since September of 2007, the Federal Reserve's aggressive
rate cuts have dragged the overnight lending rate to
a two-and-a-half year low of 3.00 percent, pushing the
US dollar down towards the low-yielding ranks with the
Swiss franc and Japanese yen. When - not if - the Fed
enacts additional rate cuts, traders that used to be
drawn to the Japanese yen as a funding currency for
carry trades may now turn to the US dollar, especially
as other central banks, such as the European Central
Bank, remain hesitant to reduce rates given persistent
price pressures stemming from oil and food costs. Inflation
has also been particularly problematic in the Asia-Pacific
region, as the Australian and New Zealand economies
depend heavily upon commodity production. Moreover,
the credit crunch that plagues the US and Europe has
not been as severe in the region, and as a result, the
Reserve Bank of Australia raised the cash target to
an 11-year high of 7.00 percent in February. Though
the Reserve Bank of New Zealand has not raised rates
since July 2007, at 8.25 percent, their overnight cash
rate is by far one of the highest among the developed
nations.
Clearly, interest rate differentials are not in favor
of the US dollar, and the lower the Federal Reserve
cuts the federal funds rate, the more likely traders
are to sell the US currency against higher-yielders
such as the Australian dollar, New Zealand dollar, and
even the euro and British pound. If the greenback draws
carry traders to the degree that the Japanese yen currently
does, the constant selling pressure on the US dollar
as the result of the carry flows will be a persistent
weight on the value of the dollar.
HOW DOES THE US FINANCE ITS DEFICIT?
- Until recently, deficits didn’t matter
- Foreigners may pare their investments in the US
- Fed may be caught between a rock and a hard place
- Start of a vicious cycle
The US current-account deficit has reached nearly $1
trillion per year. Typically, such staggeringly large
financial obligations weigh on the country’s currency,
but over the past several years, the current account
deficit has not been a problem for the U.S. The United
Sates has been able to attract at least $60-$70 billion
in capital inflows every month to offset its monthly
trade deficits of approximately $60 billion. Countries
such as China, Japan, and the Persian Gulf nations of
the Middle East have recycled their export profits back
into US government bonds. This virtuous cycle was beneficial
to all parties, as the financing helped to stimulate
US consumer demand, which in turn has allowed those
export-driven economies to sell Americans their goods.
Unfortunately, the aforementioned virtuous cycle may
be ending, only to be replaced by a vicious cycle. The
Fed's persistent lowering of interest rates has diminished
considerably the income received by foreigners on their
US investments. In China, where the economy continues
to grow at double-digit rates, the PBOC now losses more
than $4 billion per month between the interest it must
pay locally to attract deposits and the interest it
receives on the nearly US$2 trillion of reserves it
holds. Foreigners do not have to sell their current
US reserves in order to hurt the dollar; they merely
need to stop making additional purchases of US fixed-income
assets. With no further demand for US financial assets,
the demand for the US dollar will wane and the greenback
will continue to fall.
DOLLAR LOSSES ITS RESERVE STATUS SUPREMACY
- Euro—a viable alternative
- GCC—Dollar peg creates inflation
- Rebalancing from 70% -30% to 65% -35%
For the greater part of the 20th century, the dollar
has enjoyed the enviable position of being the reserve
currency for the world. That position created a natural
demand for the greenback, as most key commodities from
agriculture to energy to metals were denominated in
dollars. At the start of the 21st century, however,
the euro appeared on the scene, and because it is backed
by an economy nearly as large as the US', it provided
the first real alternative to the dollar.
Recent price action in the pair has prompted many nations
to reconsider their attachment to the US dollar, none
more so than the oil exporting nations of the Persian
Gulf. The GCC nations peg their currencies to the dollar,
and the greenback's recent weakness has created massive
inflation in their economy. The GCC makes most of its
income in dollars from the sale of oil, but purchases
more than 25% of its goods and services from the euro
zone region. As a result of a much higher EUR/USD, prices
have skyrocketed in the region to the point that many
authorities in the region have started to debate the
issue of de-pegging and even pricing oil in euros. The
trend in the GCC reflects a much larger, more secular
phenomenon of the erosion of the dollar's influence
in global trade and finance. Presently, most central
banks hold a 70% USD to 30% EUR mix in their reserves.
However, if the majority of the world’s central
banks begin to rebalance that shift even by a relatively
small percentage of 65% to 35%, such a move would unleash
massive selling flows on the currency market and drive
the dollar to even newer lows.